fbpx
Sunday, May 25, 2025

OP-ED: Energy is essential and we’re taking ours for granted

Energy is essential. Reliable and affordable energy is the single most important element underpinning humanity’s progress over the past three centuries. It seems a ridiculous thing to have to state unequivocally, like in an elementary school science class. But in Canada, some of our political leaders appear to have forgotten this basic fact.

They’ve instead chosen to play politics with energy – both with how we produce it and how you use it at home.

The most reliable and affordable energy we produce in Canada continues to be oil and natural gas. And for well over a decade, a vocal minority of aggressive activists have been pressuring governments across the country to keep Canadian natural gas and oil in the ground. Protests have been organized against every major energy project whether approved or simply proposed.

New policies attempting to limit the sector from growing are announced before the ink on the previous attempts has had a chance to dry. The result: we’ve created a situation where Canada struggles to build, well, anything.

For much of the past decade, many Canadians have been unaware of just how critical Canada’s natural gas and oil industry is. Even though more Canadians continue to support the industry than oppose it, countering a fervent, and well-funded activist movement has been a challenge. Unless you are directly employed by the industry or know someone who is, it can be a difficult ask, as most have felt they are not directly impacted by its success or by the policies targeting the sector.  

But the times, they are a-changin’. Canadians are starting to wake up to the serious problems we’ve created for ourselves, and governments around the world are beginning to walk back net-zero pledges as the reality of our indispensable need for energy hits home.

In September, United Kingdom Prime Minister, Rishi Sunak announced a sweeping rollback of net-zero initiatives. When making the announcement, he made it a priority to emphasize how it cannot be right to “impose such significant costs on working people, especially those who are already struggling to make ends meet, and to interfere so much in people’s way of life without a properly informed national debate”.

In Canada, we haven’t had a proper debate on our policy prescriptions. We’ve chosen to label and demonize any who raise the issues of costs and trade-offs as ‘deniers’ and shouted them down.

Unfortunately, for Canadians, the consequences of our insular political worldview are starting to hit hard. The carbon tax continues to rise annually, costing you more to take your family to school and to keep them warm. New fuel standards are now costing you more at the pump as well. Green building codes being proposed are adding costs to housing during one of the country’s most intense housing crises. And the government’s new electricity mandates aim to eliminate natural gas fired electricity in Canada which risks our grid’s reliability and will most certainly increase costs.

These are regressive policies that are punishing Canada’s working class.

Enter Energy United, a new grassroots advocacy organization dedicated to promoting common-sense energy and environmental policy in Canada. What is common-sense energy policy? It is policy that actually balances environmental protection with economic development (remember that promise?).

Canada’s scales are no longer balanced. We need a recalibration – and we need it fast.

To get Canada building again, we at Energy United will be pushing governments across the country to implement policies which will grow and strengthen our economy, create mortgage-paying jobs for Canadians, and yes, protect our environment.

But we need your help.

The professional activists have been the ones framing the debate and picking the policies of government. With your support, we can change the country’s conversation, have a truly national debate, and help move Canada forward.

Energy is essential and we’re taking ours for granted. 

Global oil demand will hit a record high this year. The demand for natural gas continues growing exponentially – countries have been signing long-term agreements through 2050 to ensure secure supplies. Even coal demand continues its resilience. Because the reality is fossil fuels are essential to creating reliable and affordable energy.

At Energy United, we believe Canada (and the world) will need all forms of energy to meet growing global demand. This includes wind, solar, geothermal, hydro, and of course, oil and natural gas. Canada can no longer afford to pick winners and losers.

The Canadian government has been trying to force you to change your behavior for nearly a decade. Although many of us may want to, the technology just isn’t ready for us to make the leap. And that’s okay. The cost of solar panels remains far out of reach for many, and our large, dispersed population makes winter driving a necessity.

Energy United is here to push for a better path. One that promotes technology, not taxes. A path that celebrates Canada’s energy resources and doesn’t demonize them. Most importantly, it puts you and your family first.

If Canada chooses to stay on its current road, the world will be less energy secure, our economy will shrink, Canada will lose jobs, and you’ll have less leftover.

Join Energy United to push for a better path.

VARLEY: Recycling is a myth we keep going along with

I caught a curious headline in the Toronto Star, yesterday: “City staff think Toronto should get out of the recycling business. Why? That’s a secret.”

Not much more to say about this because, well, it’s a secret…

But like most of you, I have spent the past three decades or so dutifully sorting recyclable waste – paper and cardboard, glass and plastic – from outright trash, before dragging it all curbside and giving myself a pat on the back for helping save the planet. (Okay, maybe not quite like “most of you” seeing as I’m an old guy, but you get my point.)

However, I suspect this typically furtive City Council manoeuvre may have something to do with the following: Studies started appearing a while back that strongly suggest the whole enterprise is a colossal waste of time at minimum, if not an outright deception foisted on the public at most: chiefly, that the vast majority of “recyclable plastic waste” ends up in Ontario landfills, or is exported to places like China and the Philippines. Where, likely as not, it’s burned in the open for fuel.

Ummm… that wasn’t the deal.

Turns out, it still isn’t. A May 14, 2022 Star story quoted one John Mullinder, who spent 30 years in the recycling industry, calling the whole thing “a little green lie”. Little? The same piece quoted “the plastics program manager” at an NGO called Environmental Defence, who said, “(Recycling) is just a one way ticket to garbage.”

I see.

The same story says that in 2019, Canada produced 1.9 million tonnes of plastics. Of that amount, just 12 per cent went for recycling, and an even smaller percentage was processed into a new product.

And even then, 12 per cent may be a stretch. Many other such studies peg the figure at closer to nine per cent.

Oh, but wait, say the folks at the Manitoba not-for-profit SimplyRecycle.ca: that number is “a wide misrepresentation” of the successes recycling programs in Canada have scored in recent years. You see, this figure represents “millions of tonnes of plastic annually that are kept out of landfills and environments across the world.” Which is a bit like saying an entire city block has burned down, but thank God we were able to save the sidewalks!

But for now, they comfortingly add, “The best way to eliminate plastic waste is to reduce consumption (You will eat bugs and be happy – ed.) or reuse/repurpose items. But when that’s not possible, recycling accepted materials will help keep them out of landfills.”

Help? To the tune of nine per cent of the total recyclable waste generated in this province? Against my instincts, I would counter this pie-in-the-sky assessment with that of Environmental Defence, which bills itself as a leading Canadian environmental advocacy organization: “Despite the efforts of Canadians to sort and recycle their plastics, only nine per cent of Canada’s plastic waste is recycled.”

Even then, the group adds, “This is a generous estimation since approximately 35 per cent of that ‘recycled’ plastic is sent abroad, where we can’t be sure what happens to it.” Oh, I dunno, see China, the Philippines and elsewhere, as referenced above, and think open-pit incinerators?

To its credit, Environmental Defence at least tries to diagnose the problem, which it tags to Canada’s “fragmented waste management system,” owing to a patchwork of municipal standards governing the collection and management of waste, and the need to hold manufacturers accountable for their plastic products.

(And here I thought garbage collection and disposal was the responsibility of government. Silly me.)

Maybe I’m over-simplifying things, but it seems there is a colossal market worldwide for recycled waste forged back into useful things again. Can’t recycle black plastic container lids? We built the freakin’ Avro Arrow in the 1950s. That thing could accelerate going straight up. Go figure out how to do it. No global markets for recycled material? Go off and create them. But most immediately, policymakers in Ontario – provincially and municipally – need to stop perpetuating the myth that each of us as well-meaning, ordinary individuals is making a difference.

I hope that’s what City of Toronto staff are trying to do. But then again, it’s “a secret”.

We’re simply not making a difference. And they all know it. They’ve known it for a long time.

Schools across Canada reporting uptick in student violence

Canadian teachers are seeing a spike in violence and harassment among students in their schools, a slew of recent surveys shows.

The surveys, conducted by teacher unions in Saskatchewan, Ontario and Nova Scotia, revealed alarming statistics about the prevalence and impact of violent incidents in the classrooms.

For instance, the Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario (ETFO), representing 83,000 public elementary school employees, revealed that 77% of its members have either experienced or witnessed acts of violence directed at themselves or their colleagues. 

The situation is even more dire for those working in special education, where a staggering 86% reported encountering violence. 

Additionally, more than 80% of respondents acknowledged that violence is negatively impacting the learning environment.

Results show that things have gotten worse since the beginning of the Covid-19 pandemic, when many provinces shut down schools and forced students to remain home during the school year. 

Activist groups in some provinces have called for the removal of police liaisons from school citing racial discrimination grounds. 

Last year, the Vancouver School Board narrowly voted to re-introduce police liaisons in schools for the 2023 school year citing an uptick in “troubling and violent” attacks among students. 

Saskatchewan is grappling with similar issues, as the Saskatchewan Teachers Federation, representing over 13,000 educators from pre-kindergarten to grade 12, reported an 8% increase in workplace harassment over the past five years, affecting 40% of teachers. 

Furthermore, 35% of educators indicated exposure to violence within their work environment during the same period, marking a rise from 29% in 2021.

In Nova Scotia, teachers are also witnessing a surge in violent incidents within schools. 

According to a survey conducted by the Nova Scotia Teachers Union, which represents over 10,000 public school teachers, a striking 87% of teachers have observed an uptick in aggressive behavior among students. 

The survey findings suggest that this violence is taking a toll on teachers’ mental health and overall well-being.

Edmonton Jewish group demands removal of statues honoring Ukrainian Nazi unit

The Jewish Federation of Edmonton (JFE) has called for the removal of statues and memorials honoring Ukrainian veterans with Nazi affiliations. 

In a statement released last week, the organization contended that these statues should either be taken down or relocated to museums, where they can serve as educational tools with proper historical context.

Two specific sites have come under scrutiny by the JFE. 

The organization pointed to the presence of a memorial at St. Michael’s Cemetery in Edmonton, which honors Ukrainian members of the Nazi Waffen SS 14th Galicia Division. 

Additionally, a statue of Roman Shukhevych stands outside the Ukrainian Youth Unity Complex in north Edmonton. The JFE notes that the statue has remained in place since the 1970s with limited public attention.

Shukhevych held a leadership position within the Nachtigall Battalion of the Organization of Ukrainian Nationalists (OUN). 

Later, this unit became the Schutzmannschaft Battalion 201, which has been linked to multiple troubling incidents, including pogroms in eastern Poland and the mass murders of Jews in June and July 1941.

In a strongly worded statement from community relations co-chairs Steve Shafir and Adam Zepp, the Jewish Federation of Edmonton stressed that honoring such individuals “completely whitewashes the atrocities that they have committed.” 

The presence of these statues is deemed offensive to the community, Holocaust survivors and their families, the statement said.

The controversy comes on the heels of controversy stemming from former Galicia division veteran Yaroslav Hunka receiving a standing ovation in the House of Commons during Ukrainian President Volodomyr Zelensky’s visit.

In response, the JFE is calling on the Alberta government to mandate Holocaust education in the core curriculum to prevent the recurrence of such events and to honor those who stood on the right side of history.

11,000 Ontario patients died on surgical waiting lists last year

Thousands of Ontarians died waiting for healthcare last year, according to a new report.

The report from CUPE’s Ontario Council of Hospital Unions (OCHU) found that 11,000 Ontarians died last year while on waiting lists for surgeries, CT scans and MRIs over the course of 2022.

Currently, there are over 200,000 Ontarians still on the province’s surgical waitlist.

“I’m medically burnt out. It’s a fight. I have a little son, he’s five years old, and I promised him I would be at his wedding,” said 38-year old Jordanne Bialo, an Ontario patient who has been waiting for answers and treatment after falling ill in October 2020. 

“That’s why I fight – for my family. It’s a full time job. It’s a full time job to be a patient right now.” Bialo told CityNews Toronto. 

Bialo said that it took three years before she received a diagnosis from a doctor about her rare genetic tumour syndrome, known as Cowden syndrome. She will require a double mastectomy, which currently has a minimum wait time of one-year. 

Her experience of long wait times is becoming all too common. 

“I am full of these tumours that can turn any minute – it’s like Russian roulette and I just have to continue to keep pushing,” she said. 

Bialo had a hysterectomy in July, after spending a year and a half waiting to see a gynecologist. Once she was able to see a doctor, they discovered four additional tumours on her back.

“They told me I need imaging done sooner than later, I’ve been on the phone with the hospital for the last two weeks, nobody answers,” said Bialo. “I’m constantly waiting, it’s a battle,” said Bialo, who is still struggling to get an appointment for a CT scan. 

The 21-page report published by the OCHU revealed that only 56% of patients who require a CT scan have received one within the necessary timeframe and the number dropped down to 35% for those who need MRIs.

Additionally, the report found a dramatic uptick in staff vacancies at hospitals, up 19% since last year with thousands of hospital positions remaining unfilled. 

“We are one of the wealthiest jurisdictions in the world and we can afford, and we have a moral responsibility, to provide quality care to the people of this province,” said president of the OCHU Michael Hurley.

The OCHU is demanding that Doug Ford’s administration take action and make serious investments into the province’s healthcare system.  

“The government is expanding capacity across the province, getting shovels in the ground for nearly 60 hospital developments over 10 years that will add thousands of beds across the province, to connect Ontarians to the care they need now and into the future,” wrote a spokesperson for the Ontario’s Minister of Health. 

The report discovered that over 2,000 people died on waiting lists for surgeries in 2022, an increase of nearly 50% from 2021. An additional 9,400 patients died awaiting MRIs and CT scans.

“The hardest part is my son, my little guy. He’s the most amazing kid in the world, and he is suffering seeing me sick,” said Bialo, who said she’s fighting with all her strength not to become part of those statistics. “I have to get better for him.”

Elon Musk and others react to Trudeau’s “shameful” bid to regulate podcasts

The Liberal government has come under intense scrutiny on social media after the Canadian Radio-television Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) said it would be moving to regulate podcast providers and streaming services. 

The contentious decision has drawn the ire of prominent figures, including Elon Musk, journalist Glenn Greenwald, and Chris Pavlovski, the CEO of Rumble.

Accusations of censorship were prompted when the CRTC issued a news release outlining its plans to expand its regulatory scope into the world of podcasts, social media services, and online streaming platforms. 

The central provision of this announcement requires “online streaming services that offer podcasts” to formally register with the government if they earn over $10 million annually, allowing for increased regulatory control.

Elon Musk, CEO of X and Tesla, expressed his strong disapproval of the move in a post on Sunday. 

“Trudeau is trying to crush free speech in Canada. Shameful,” Musk posted. 

Musk’s post has been seen by over 38 million people and has been liked over 305,000 times at the time of writing. 

The X CEO was responding to a post by journalist Glenn Greenwald who accused the Trudeau government of overseeing a repressive censorship regime. 

“The Canadian government, armed with one of the world’s most repressive online censorship schemes, announces that all “online streaming services that offer podcasts” must formally register with the government to permit regulatory controls,” posted Greenwald. 

Chris Pavlovski, CEO of the video streaming platform Rumble, also lamented the development. 

“Canada is no longer part of the free world. As a Canadian, I’ve never been more embarrassed than I have in the past few weeks,” posted Pavlovski. 

The CRTC’s initial step in regulating digital media will require podcast providers operating in Canada and earning over $10 million annually to formally register with the commission. 

While proponents argue that this move is aimed at ensuring a level playing field in the media, opponents claim it to be an infringement on free speech and an unnecessary intrusion into content creation.

Ontario’s minimum wage set to increase on Sunday

Ontario will be raising the provincial minimum wage on Sunday to $16.55 an hour from the current rate of $15.50, regardless of one’s employment status as a full-time or part-time employee.

The government claims that the increase is expected to benefit over 900,000 workers in Ontario who are currently working for $15.50 per hour. Those who work full time at minimum wage can expect to see an extra $2,200 in earnings annually from the increase. 

The student minimum wage will also be increased by $1 per hour, going from $14.60 to $15.60. Student minimum wage applies to people under the age of 18 who work for 28 hours or less per week during the active school season and throughout the summer.

Those who are employed but work from home will earn an increase of $1.15, from $17.05 per hour t0 $18.20, according to CP24 News

Guides for hunting, fishing and wilderness tours will also get an increase in their daily pay, going from $77.60 to $82.85 if they work less than five hours per day. Employees in those fields who work more than five hours per day will see their daily pay increase from $155.25 to $165.75. 

Ontario already has one of the higher minimum wages when compared to other provinces and territories. Only British Columbia and the Yukon have a higher minimum wage at $16.75 and $16.77, respectively. 

The provinces with the lowest minimum wage are Saskatchewan at $14 per hour and New Brunswick at $14.75 per hour.  

Nova Scotia, Newfoundland and P.E.I. all share the same minimum wage of $15 per hour. 

Quebec and Manitoba have similar minimum wages at $15.25 and $15.30, respectively. 

Nunavut’s minimum wage is currently $16 per hour and the Northwest Territories is $16.05. 

Canada also has a federal minimum wage that applies to all federally regulated private sectors like banks, interprovincial air, road, rail and marine transportation and the post office. The federal minimum wage was increased earlier this year in April, rising from $15.55 to $16.65 per hour.

The Ontario Living Wage Network analyzes how much the province’s hourly wage would need to be to provide the proper income to cover the cost of living on an annual basis. Their most recent analysis concluded that the Ontario minimum wage had not been properly updated to compete with the increased cost of living. 

The network’s latest report found that the living wage needed to be over $19 per hour in most regions of the province and $23 an hour in the Greater Toronto Area. 

In 2021, the Ford government announced that the minimum wage would increase from $14.35 to $15 per hour in January 2022. It was later increased that same year from $15 to $15.50 in October. 

Still, labour advocates have called on the provincial government to raise the minimum wage again to $20 per hour.

CRTC will require podcasts, online streaming to register with gov

Canada’s broadcasting regulatory body, the Canadian Radio-television Telecommunications Commission (CRTC) published a news release announcing that it would require podcast providers, social media services and online streaming platforms to register with the government.  

“We are developing a modern broadcasting framework that can adapt to changing circumstances. To do that, we need broad engagement and robust public records. We appreciate the significant participation during this first phase and look forward to hearing a diversity of perspectives at our contributions proceeding in November,” said CRTC Chairperson and Chief Executive Officer Vicky Eatrides. 

The first thing the CRTC plans to do is force all podcast providers that operate in Canada and earn over $10 million annually to formally register with the CRTC. 

“The CRTC is setting out which online streaming services need to provide information about their activities in Canada. Online streaming services that operate in Canada, offer broadcasting content, and earn $10 million or more in annual revenues will need to complete a registration form by November 28, 2023. Registration collects basic information, is only required once and can be completed in just a few steps,” read the release. 

Secondly, “the CRTC is setting conditions for online streaming services to operate in Canada. These conditions take effect today and require certain online streaming services to provide the CRTC with information related to their content and subscribership. The decision also requires those services to make content available in a way that is not tied to a specific mobile or Internet service.”

There is no shortage of confusion surrounding who and what will be affected in online entertainment regarding the CRTC’s new powers since the passing of Bill C-11. 

Currently, content creators earning under $10 million a year and post content onto their own website will remain unaffected, however the social media services which platform these content creators will have to register with the CRTC. According to University of Ottawa Canada Research Chair in Internet and E-commerce Law Michael Geist, due to the way Bill C-11 is written, this would encompass individual podcast creators who meet the benchmark.

“Given the government’s regular insistence that “platforms are in and users are out”, it begs the question why some users are, by the Commission’s own admission, now in,” wrote Geist in response to the announcement on Monday. 

If the online services are only providing a platform for video games or audio books they will not be required to register.

The CRTC plans to provide a list of all online services that have registered with them on their website. 

Registry with the CRTC applies to not just those living and creating in Canada but also  foreign online streaming services that are accessible to users in Canada. 

These decisions have been made as a result of numerous public consultations that were first launched in May. Another consultation remains ongoing, which asks respondents what contributions should be made by legacy media broadcasters and online streaming services to support Canadian and Indigenous content.

The CRTC announced that it will be holding a three-week public proceeding for the ongoing consultation, which will begin on November 20, 2023. The proceeding is expected “to hear from 129 intervenors who represent a broad range of interests.” 

The Andrew Lawton Show | Justin Trudeau is coming for your podcasts

Thanks to the Liberal government’s Bill C-11, the CRTC is expanding its regulatory reach to online content – including podcasts. On Friday, the CRTC launched the first stage of this by requiring streaming services – including websites that host podcasts and other media content – to register and “provide information about their activities in Canada.” True North’s Andrew Lawton says this is the beginning of the end of the open internet in Canada. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation’s Kris Sims joins to discuss.

Also, in every country that has legalized doctor-assisted suicide, the numbers of casualties of it balloons as safeguards are lifted. Canada is proving to be an extreme example of this according to a new feature in the National Review by journalist Alexander Raikin. He joins Andrew to talk about how death care has replaced health care.

SUBSCRIBE TO THE ANDREW LAWTON SHOW

The Daily Brief | Did you recognize Truth and Reconciliation Day?

A Leger poll has revealed that almost half of Canadians did not do anything to recognize Truth and Reconciliation Day, which took place on Saturday Sept. 30.

Plus, 602 transgender minors have had their breasts surgically removed in Canada, according to a shocking new report.

And Waterloo City Council adopted an amended bylaw, which seeks to ban communications that make people “feel harassed.”

Tune into The Daily Brief with Cosmin Dzsurdzsa and Lindsay Shepherd!

SUBSCRIBE TO THE DAILY BRIEF

Related stories