fbpx
Friday, July 11, 2025

Government hiding online censorship consultation results, advocacy group claims

The Vancouver-based internet freedom advocacy group Open Media is slamming the Liberal government for hiding the results of a consultation on its proposed plan to regulate online content from the public. 

According to Blacklock’s Reporter, Open Media Campaign Director Matthew Hatfield claimed that the vast amount of criticism the government received in the past few weeks is being held up behind a veil of secrecy. 

“If our government won’t tell us what they’ve heard from us, how can we know if they’re listening?” said Hatfield.  

“In a shocking move, our government has refused to publish the results of last month’s consultation on their proposed plan to censor and surveil the internet. Any legislation that could affect our online speech is among the most sensitive our government could propose, yet the government is keeping this crucial criticism on those proposed plans hidden from the public.”

According to Hatfield, Open Media members alone submitted 9,000 submissions against the proposal prior to the consultation period closing on September 25, 2021. 

Among the groups which also submitted counter-arguments to the plan include the Independent Press Gallery of Canada (IPG), University of Toronto’s Citizen Lab and a number of other organizations dedicated to civil liberties and free speech online. 

“The IPG opposes the proposal and expresses a serious concern to the harmful effects on freedom of expression and principles of law that will ensue if the government moves forward with the proposal. We expect that the government will take our criticisms into account and will cease its pursuit of the proposal in its current form,” IPG President and True North Founder Candice Malcolm wrote.

Although the federal government has not published the results of its consultation, Heritage Minister Steven Guilbeault’s office has confirmed that it did not receive any messages of support for the law. 

Other critics of the proposed law, including federal judges and human rights advocates have separately labelled the plan “incoherent” and “unconstitutional.” 

MALCOLM: The uninspiring sameness of Canada’s political parties

The most striking feature of the recent federal election was the amount of overlap between the parties when it came to their platforms as well as their overall governing philosophies.

We’ve come to a point where the Liberals, Conservatives, New Democrats, Bloc and Greens all have the same opinion on virtually every political issue that matters to Canadians.

On healthcare, fiscal federalism, bilingualism, high taxes, budget deficits, the size of the public service, childcare, affordable housing, reconciliation, the environment, immigration, foreign policy, gun control, abortion, speech censorship, COVID restrictions, lockdowns, vaccines and even some variation of a universal basic income, they all agree!

Sure, each party has a slightly different way of framing the issues — tinkering with the various rates and rebates here and there — but, overall, it would be nearly impossible for the average voter to name the party behind the big-ticket platform ideas of the major parties.

Which party proposed doubling the Canada Workers Benefit to give low-wage workers a rebate on federal income tax?

Which party proposed a tax-free savings account for first-time homeowners under the age of 40?

Which party proposed a two-year ban on foreign ownership of homes? (Trick question, they all agree on that one!)

One of the biggest announcements from the Conservative campaign was an idea to allow working mothers to continue collecting maternity leave payments while working part-time. The kicker: a Liberal policy already allows this.

The uninspiring sameness of the major parties led us to a status quo outcome. Canadians were indifferent to the various pitches, and thus, retreated to old habits and cast the same vote as they did last time.

(The exception came by way of Maxine Bernier and the People’s Party of Canada, who ran on a very different set of issues and nearly tripled their vote count. Bernier’s outside-the-box ideas, however, led much of the media — also cursed by toxic groupthink and rigid boring sameness — to demonize and slander Bernier and call him every horrid name in the book.)

The Conservatives once offered the occasional spark of originality in Canada’s painfully dull political system. They sometimes resisted media-induced conformity and would say ‘no’ to the left’s insistence that we all have the exact same opinion on every single topic.

Conservatives used to push back, ever so slightly, on the latest leftist fad — be it on fanatical climate alarmism, open borders immigration or accusing Canada of committing the worst forms of crimes, including genocide.

But it seems those days are behind us. Under Erin O’Toole, the party appears committed to whitewash itself into a true big-L Liberal Party.

Last week, following what I’m told was a very heated caucus meeting on the topic, O’Toole sent out party whip Blake Richards to oppose the Liberal government’s vaccine requirement for all MPs.

“As we said during the election, workplace health and safety can be assured through vaccination or the demonstration of a recent negative rapid test result,” said Richards.

“We cannot agree to seven MPs, meeting in secret, deciding which of the 338 MPs, just elected by Canadians, can enter the House of Commons to represent their constituents,” he said.

I’m told the Tory caucus vehemently opposes vaccine mandates, while O’Toole — weakened from an election loss and worried about a leadership review, which can now be initiated with a letter from just 24 MPs — wants to fall in line with the preferred policy of much of the media and Liberal Party.

O’Toole allowed caucus to win the day, but 24 hours later, speaking to TVO’s Steve Paikin, O’Toole changed his mind and contradicted Richards by saying that his party will respect the Liberal rule on vaccines.

For 24 hours, there was a hint of daylight between the Liberals and Conservatives. That, apparently, was too much for O’Toole, who seems to prefer the position of total Liberal conformity.

Is Ontario’s COVID response heading in the right direction?

The Ontario government has finally unveiled its reopening plan.

While public health measures such as vaccine passports and mandatory masks remain in place for the next few months, the government has set a timeline for when the province can fully return to normal.

What do you think of Doug Ford’s reopening plan?

Anthony Furey discusses in his latest video.

Nearly half of Canadians want political system completely reformed: Pew Research

Almost half of the country desires significant political reform, a new Pew Research poll comparing attitudes towards governments across the developed world reveals. 

The poll surveyed thousands of people over the phone from 16 advanced economies including Canada, the US, Australia, Japan and South Korea. 

When Canadians were asked if the political system “needs to be completely reformed/needs major changes,” 47% of those polled agreed with the statement. 

In comparison to other nations, however, the desire for systemic change in Canada is relatively low. Other countries such as the US reported 85% of people desiring reform and in Italy 89% of people wanted change. 

“Even in places where the demand for significant political reform is relatively low, substantial minorities say their system needs minor changes. In all of the publics surveyed, fewer than three-in-ten say the political system should not be changed at all,” wrote Pew Research. 

On the question of whether the economic and healthcare system needs to be reformed, 46% and 43% of Canadians responded in the affirmative respectively. 

Despite the desire for change, most Canadians remain satisfied with how well democracy is working in their own country with 66% saying it is working well and 33% who are not satisfied. 

When broken down further, people who viewed Canada’s pandemic performance negatively were more likely to desire serious reform politically. In that group, 71% of people wanted significant change, while among those who saw pandemic policies positively only 32% were desiring reform. 

“People who believe their country is doing a poor job of dealing with the pandemic are consistently more likely to say they are dissatisfied with the way their democracy is working and to call for political reform,” wrote researchers. 

“The belief that one’s country is doing a bad job of dealing with the pandemic is also linked to a desire for health care reform.”

Manitoba rural crime bills help farm families feel safe, agricultural group says

Farmers and agricultural groups are lauding two bills passed by the Manitoba government meant to protect communities from rural crime. 

The President of Keystone Agricultural Producers Bill Campbell was among the industry leaders who praised the bill as a necessary measure for increased security in rural areas. 

“Improvements to trespassing and biosecurity laws are important steps in ensuring Manitoba farm families feel safe and biosecurity protocols are maintained,” said Campbell. 

One of the two laws, Bill 63, went into effect on Friday, October 15, 2021. The legislation, titled the Petty Trespasses Amendment and Occupiers’ Liability Amendment Act, makes entry onto certain rural premises without permission an offence. The bill includes premises such as farms and storage facilities within its scope. 

Meanwhile, on October 8, 2021, a separate law, Bill 62, otherwise known as the Animal Diseases Amendment Act was also enacted. Bill 62 provides increased protection to “biosecurity zones” such as farms and facilities where animals are housed and processed. 

Critics have accused the Manitoba government of unfairly targeting animal rights activists, but proponents of the law have stated that the bills extend beyond simple activist activities and are meant to ensure the safety of animals as well as farmers. 

“That’s part of it. Obviously, if people are entering a facility unauthorized and posing a danger to … the safety and biosecurity, this is what’s really looking to address that,” said Agriculture Minister Blaine Pedersen.

“It is not specifically for [activists], but it does cover that element.”

Last week, Manitoba RCMP announced that rural police reported crime rates have dropped significantly over the last year. 

Between August 2020 and August 2021, rural communities in Manitoba saw an average 11% decrease in crime. 

The drop was experienced across several crime categories including assault and robbery which fell by 29% and property crimes which fell by 23% in the province’s East District. 

What would Canada’s COVID response look like without social media?

Are government responses to COVID-19 based on the social media mob? In some cases in Canada, it definitely seems like the case. But what if social media didn’t exist?

Would Canada’s response to COVID be more balanced and more similar to how the country handled the SARS outbreak? Let us know what you think.

Anthony Furey discusses in his latest video.

Vaccine passes are a road to global surveillance says former privacy commissioner

Ontario’s former information and privacy commissioner Dr. Ann Cavoukian is raising the alarm about the potential for vaccine passes to be used by governments to spy on their citizens. 

Cavoukian, who also holds a senior fellowship at Ryerson University’s Ted Rogers Leadership Centre and is the executive director of the Global Privacy and Security by Design Centre, made the comments in an interview with the Epoch Times. 

“Wherever you have to give your vaccine passport, it’s not just the QR code. They’re asking you for identification—your driver’s licence, your phone number—there’s personal information linked to it,” Cavoukian told the outlet. 

“There will be geolocation data associated with where you were, and at what time. [Governments] can engage in surveillance and pull these all together and know where you were, at what time, who you were with.” 

The Ontario government has claimed that the vaccine passport model they introduced on October 15, 2021 provides “greater security and privacy protection” by way of using a QR code which is essentially an advanced barcode that can contain more information. 

However, as experts have pointed out, vaccine passports are not impervious to abuse or attacks from cybercriminals or foreign entities. 

A group of so-called hackers notified the Quebec government that it was able to access the QR codes of several high-profile politicians, including Quebec Premier Francois Legault by way of a loophole in the system. 

Additionally, as Cavoukian explains, governments have not indicated when an end to the vaccine passport system will take place. 

“What often happens is when there’s an emergency, the privacy laws get lifted because it’s an emergency situation and additional measures are introduced. Then, when the emergency ends, those privacy-invasive measures often continue,” she said.

“That’s what happened with 9/11, with the Patriot Act, and others. And so my fear is that people are going to just expect to have to reveal vaccine status on a go-forward basis, even when the pandemic ends.”

On Friday, the Ontario government unveiled its reopening plan, which aimed to lift the province’s vaccine passport system in early 2022. However, their plan is contingent on factors such as case numbers and hospital capacity. 

According to Cavoukian, this kind of data gathering will create a “global digital infrastructure of surveillance” which is constantly being updated by “hundreds and thousands of sites that are obtaining these vaccine passports from you.”

“With vaccine passports, people are being forced, they’re demanded to reveal their vaccine status. And that should be no one’s business except for the individual and their own doctor,” said Cavoukian. 

Price of propane up 296% in parts of Canada

In addition to the cost of fuel and gasoline, Canadians have had to deal with a spike in propane prices across the country.

According to the Financial Post, propane has spiked in the last three months in parts of Canada by a shocking 296%. 

ATB Capital Markets has reported that propane jumped from US$0.25 per gallon to US$1.40 per gallon. Additionally, Bloomberg reports that the prices were the highest they have been in over 7.5 years. 

The US Energy Information Administration (EIA) recently warned that in the US, Americans will have to pay higher heating costs this winter as propane and natural gas are expected to rise even further. 

“The higher global and domestic energy prices that are resulting from economies beginning to grow again are going to translate into larger household bills for energy this winter,” EIA acting administrator Steve Nally said.

“Exports now make up a larger proportion of the total propane market, the total amount produced and distributed through the system, than is true for gas. Similar to natural gas, we’re in a situation where prices for the arbitrage opportunity are so wide that you’re going to keep exporting as much as you can.”

Recent Statistics Canada data reveals that inflation is the highest it has been since February 2003, as Canadians struggle to deal with rising costs of goods across the board. 

The latest data indicates that inflation is currently at 4.4%

“Since the pandemic began (beginning of March 2020) the Bank of Canada has printed more than $380 billion,” Canadian Taxpayers Federation Federal Director Franco Terrazzano told True North on Wednesday. 

“The stats are showing what everyone is feeling: pain from sky-high cost of living. It’s time for the feds to take the printing press out of overdrive, rein in the overspending and provide tax relief.”

Goods like beef have shot up 13% at grocery stores, while the cost of gasoline has risen a shocking 32.8%. 

Conservative Party leader Erin O’Toole chastised the Liberal government on social media this week for the high prices. 

“Liberal mismanagement of our economy has led to the highest levels of inflation since early 2003. The cost of everything is skyrocketing. The Trudeau Liberals need to wake up and realize the mess they have created,” tweeted O’Toole on Thursday. 

RCMP union attempts to trademark potential Alberta provincial police force names

The RCMP union is trying to trademark possible names of a hypothetical Alberta provincial police force to throw a wrench in Alberta’s pursuit of its own independent law enforcement agency.

According to online records, the National Police Federation (NPF) applied last February to trademark the following names with the Canadian Intellectual Property Office: “Alberta Police Force,” “Alberta Police Department,” “Alberta Provincial Police,” “Alberta Police Service,” and “Alberta Provincial Police Service.” 

The trademarks have not been approved and are still under consideration. 

Kenney has put forward the idea of creating a police service under the province’s jurisdiction as a way to break free from the federal model and better address Alberta’s specific law enforcement needs. 

“Especially in rural (areas), one of the issues is unacceptably long police response times. I think we can do better with a community police model. That’s what the city people have, with municipal police forces, in Calgary, Edmonton, Lethbridge and four other communities. If it’s good enough for city people, why isn’t it good enough for rural people to have their own local police force?” Kenney said in August. “That’s what an Alberta provincial police force would provide.”

NPF president Brian Sauvé claims “public polling” doesn’t support the idea, despite surveys showing otherwise. 

“We don’t believe it should be easy for Premier Kenney to proceed unchallenged along the path of this politically-motivated proposal to replace the RCMP with a new provincial police service — which public polling tells us just isn’t what Albertans want, and continues to lack any transparency and accountability,” Sauvé said.

In reality, polls indicate that more Albertans (46%) supported a provincial police force than those who didn’t (39%). 

“The government will not be deterred by petty attempts of obstruction. Any decision will ultimately be made in the best interest of Albertans,” said Alberta Justice Minister Kaycee Madu in response to the NPF application.

According to a trademark expert and University of alberta professor Cameron Hutchison, it is likely that the union will not be granted the trademarks. 

“Normally, you have competitors and people who want to use the same word for their products. We have Pears soap or Dove soap, right? We don’t want to allow trademarks over (the word) soap because then nobody else can use them,” Hutchison told the Edmonton Journal. 

“So either one of those would be a bar to getting a trademark, and I don’t see how they clear that hurdle.” 

Ford stands his ground amid fake news narrative

It’s Fake News Friday on The Candice Malcolm Show! Candice calls out the legacy media for their dishonesty and highlights the most outrageous examples of the media misleading Canadians.

This week, the legacy media went after Ontario Premier Doug Ford for making “anti-immigrant” comments, when in reality he was complimenting new Canadians and talking about work shortages and the need for more immigrants in the province.

Plus, the Saskatchewan Health Authority publishes medical misinformation and the left eats its own by setting its targets on Margaret Atwood.

These stories and more on The Candice Malcolm Show. Tune in now!

SUBSCRIBE TO THE CANDICE MALCOLM SHOW

Related stories