fbpx
Saturday, September 6, 2025

MALCOLM: Partnering with the government is a lose-lose situation

The government should not pick winners and losers in the economy.

For as long as I’ve been following politics and public policy, I’ve heard this phrase emphasized and repeated — especially in fiscally conservative and libertarian circles.

The idea is that the free market should determine which businesses succeed — based on pricing, how well they serve their customers, and so on — and the government should not be in the business of subsidizing businesses.

The underlying idea is that if a company receives a government handout, they have an unfair advantage over their competitors.

In Canada, in practice, however, the opposite is true.

Look at Bombardier Inc., the Montreal-based aerospace manufacturing company.

In 2017, the Trudeau government bailed out Bombardier with a $373-million federal loan. At the same time, the Liberal government in Quebec also provided a taxpayer-funded bailout to the tune of $1 billion.

But Bombardier is anything but a winner. About 18 months after receiving bailouts and favourable loans from their friends in the Liberal party, Bombardier announced it was cutting about 5,000 jobs globally — 3,000 of them here in Canada.

This week, shares in the company dropped to an all-time low after Bombardier acknowledged its 2019 revenues failed to meet targets. The price plummeted by one-third of its value in a single day.

Bombardier is not alone.

A year ago, grocery giant Loblaw received a $12-million handout from the Liberal government to replace its refrigerators with new low-emission alternatives. Loblaw is a $25-billion company and the largest food retailer in Canada.

Why on earth would a profitable and successful corporation need a bailout from taxpayers to improve its own technology?

It was a slap in the face to taxpayers and employees earlier this month when Loblaw pointed to its own technology as the cause of major job cuts.

The company announced it would be laying off 700 workers and closing two distribution centres in Quebec and Ontario, noting the positions would be replaced by automation.

Was it the same technology that the federal government just “invested” in?

This brings us to our friends in the media, who are also cursed when it comes to government handouts.

This week we learned CBC’s ad revenues fell by over 37% in 2019, falling by $65 million from 2018.

Businesses are no longer interested in buying ads on CBC because Canadians, by and large, are no longer tuning into the state broadcaster. Fewer than 1% of Canadians watch local evening news on CBC.

CBC’s overall market share is down to just 5%, while its dedicated news channel, CBC News Network, has just a 1.4% market share.

Fewer Canadians than ever before are watching CBC and, meanwhile, the state broadcaster receives more money than ever — a $1.2-billion annual subsidy.

Taxpayers are paying CBC to remain lazy, biased and, worst of all, uninteresting.

Instead of learning that the government should not be funding and bailing out media companies, the Trudeau government instead should set up a new scheme to extend taxpayer handouts to more even journalists.

Last fall, it announced a $595-million slush fund to bailout establishment newspapers (including Postmedia, which owns the Sun).

If these media companies are run anything like other corporate welfare-receiving firms, it will likely lead to more complacency, more mistakes and more layoffs to come.

Partnering with the government is a lose-lose situation. Taxpayers are on the hook for bailing out failing businesses and those businesses continue with bad habits that lead to more failure.

Politicians may not learn their lesson, but perhaps business owners will. Partnering with the government is the kiss of death.

SHEPHERD: A mandatory high school English class that studies only indigenous authors?

The Ottawa Catholic school board wants to increase the diversity of literature being studied in their Grade 11 English courses throughout the district. But rather than featuring literary works drawn from many different genres, historical periods and cultures, the school board has decided that the mandatory “English” class will be renamed “English: Understanding Contemporary First Nations, Métis, and Inuit Voices,” and only feature indigenous writers, at the exclusion of all other cultures and ethnicities. 

An article in the Ottawa Citizen earlier this week proclaimed the Grade 11 English students at the Ottawa Catholic School Board will be “ditching Shakespeare and Margaret Atwood in favour of studying literature by Indigenous authors like Richard Wagamese and Tanya Talaga.”

I should have reached out to Margaret Atwood for comment, and ask her how it feels to be an award-winning, iconic author that has been abruptly “ditched.”

The switch to a 100% indigenous reading list will be instituted across the Ottawa Catholic school board by 2022. Ottawa’s English public school board has already made the switch to an all-indigenous Grade 11 reading list, and the Greater Essex County District School Board has vowed to change its curriculum by the end of this year.

Apologists may argue that the mandatory all-indigenous course is only for one year, and that students have every other grade to study writers from other cultures and races. However, I would counter that Grade 11 and Grade 12 English are the last two English courses students will take in high school, which means for many students, those are the last two English classes they will take for the rest of their lives. Being exposed to works from a variety of traditions, eras and cultures should be a priority in the upper years of high school, when students have had the most time to refine their reading comprehension, critical thinking and writing skills. And after all, don’t we as a nation proclaim to “celebrate diversity” and affirm “diversity is our strength?”

It is also false to act as if Grade 11 students will not have encountered indigenous literature or indigenous history in prior years. These changes are being made because of The Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s 94 calls to action, which includes mandatory age-appropriate curriculum on indigenous history and residential schools from kindergarten to Grade 12. By Grade 11, any student that’s actually showed up to class in the last decade will not be ignorant to Canada’s history of residential schools. (Here in British Columbia, I was helping my little brother with a worksheet on residential schools when he was in Grade 5). 

According to the Ottawa Citizen, literature commonly studied in the traditional English course at the Ottawa Catholic School Board includes either MacBeth or Othello by William Shakespeare; Night by Elie Wiesel; and The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Students would also study short stories from authors that might include Margaret Atwood, Margaret Laurence, Sinclair Ross, and Jamaica Kincaid.

From the various English 11 course outlines available online, it appears students are reading everything from George Orwell’s Animal Farm to Khaled Hosseini’s The Kite Runner.

Strangely, while the new all-indigenous Grade 11 English courses are mandatory, the Ontario Ministry of Education simultaneously maintains that there is no mandatory or recommended reading list for Grade 11 English. The ministry only mandates that classes must provide material that reflects the diversity of Canada.

By all means, it should be assured that works by indigenous authors are included in English classes. But to make the mandatory Grade 11 English course study the works of only indigenous authors, at the exclusion of all other ethnicities and cultures? That isn’t consistent with the tenets of diversity and inclusion.

Male employment decreases as manufacturing jobs disappear across Canada: StatsCan

A fifteen-year long study by Statistics Canada has concluded that male employment has declined substantially as the manufacturing sector retreats across Canada, with men in Ontario seeing suffering the most.

The study, looking at data from 2000 to 2015, found that the number of men aged 21 to 55 employed full-time declined by 5% nationwide, in line with declines in the manufacturing sector.

“The decline in men’s full-year, full-time employment rates was generally more pronounced in census metropolitan areas (CMAs) and census agglomerations (CAs) that experienced larger-than-average declines in the relative importance of the manufacturing sector,” the study reads.

Statistics Canada found that the number of men working full-time in the census areas of Windsor, Oshawa, St. Catharines–Niagara and Kitchener–Cambridge–Waterloo decreased by 10%, twice the national average.

Statistics Canada concluded that approximately two-thirds of the decline in men’s employment across cities in Ontario can be attributed to declines in the manufacturing sector.

From 2000 to 2015, all provinces except Newfoundland & Labrador saw a decline in full-time male employment.

While wages for men in Canada increased overall since 2000, in manufacturing cities in Ontario wages have either not changed or declined.

Statistics Canada adds that the decline in manufacturing has not been observed to impact women’s employment.

Since 2015 the downward trend in the manufacturing industry has remained in Ontario. By mid-2020 the Nemak automotive parts plant in Windsor is expected to close, putting nearly 300 people out of work.

The plight of men in traditional industries has become increasingly apparent in Canada, whether it is in manufacturing or the natural resources sector.

In November 20% of young men in Alberta were unemployed, doubling in just six months. Depressed oil prices and a failing energy sector have significantly reduced economic opportunity in the province.

In British Columbia, the forestry industry is on the verge of collapse. It has been estimated that 80% of the province’s coastal forestry sector is currently down, reporting thousands in job losses in recent years.

In November the Manufacturing and natural resources sectors saw significant job losses, with those sectors losing 27,500 and 6,500 jobs respectively.

Elected B.C. chief says LNG pipeline is creating Indigenous jobs

An elected B.C. First Nations chief said that the LNG pipeline is much-needed and is lifting communities get out of poverty.

“In order to achieve independent nations, we need independent members. The opportunities that are available for today’s generation and future generations of First Nations people that participate in these projects are life changing. They’re nation changing,” said Chief Coun. Crystal Smith.

The pipeline is currently at the centre of a dispute between the project owners and hereditary Wet’suwet’en chiefs. 

Despite opposition from the single Wet’suwet’en hereditary clan, 20 elected First Nations bands have signed agreements in support of the project. 

Both the B.C. Supreme Court and the province’s NDP government have also come out in support of the project’s construction. 

Justice Marguerite Church ruled that protests against the project have caused “irreparable harm” and that the tribe’s Indigenous laws are not a recognized part of Canadian law. 

“There has been no process by which Wet’suwet’en customary laws have been recognized in this manner. While Wet’suwet’en customary laws clearly exist on their own independent footing, they are not recognized as being an effectual part of Canadian law,”  wrote Justice Church. 

The U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination has spoken out against the project and ordered Canada to stop three ongoing resource developments, including the LNG pipeline. 

B.C.’s appointed Human Rights Commissioner Kasari Govender called on Canada to obey the U.N’s directive and put an end to the pipeline’s construction. 

“I join CERD [Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination] in urging Canada to immediately cease the forced eviction of Wet’suwet’en and Secwepemc peoples, to prohibit the use of lethal weapons, and to guarantee no force will be used against them. This is a matter of fundamental human rights,” said Govender in a statement. 

RCMP have secured the site and set up checkpoints due to protestors seeking to sabotage the project. Earlier this month, RCMP officers discovered fuel-soaked rags and containers of gasoline near the road leading to the construction site. 

“These concerning items have been brought to the attention of the Wet’suwet’en Hereditary Chiefs. They have also been advised that the RCMP has entered into a criminal investigation under Section 247 of the Criminal Code for Traps Likely to Cause Bodily Harm,” said the RCMP.

KNIGHT: Foreign funded enviro loons are still imposing their will on Canadians

B.C.’s newly minted Human Rights Commissioner Kasari Govender thinks Canada should defer to the United Nations directive to abandon three resource energy projects including the TMX pipeline. 

Somehow in her mind Canada’s sovereignty should take a back seat to the hand-wringers and pearl clutchers at the UN. 

Given the countries appointed to sit on the UN’s Human Rights Council, it’s hard to take them seriously on any issue. Nor should Canada surrender her sovereignty to the UN.

Govender tries to cloak this intrusion into the policies and politics of a sovereign country by trying to paint energy projects as somehow racist. 

“I join CERD [Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination] in urging Canada to immediately cease the forced eviction of Wet’suwet’en and Secwepemc peoples, to prohibit the use of lethal weapons, and to guarantee no force will be used against them.”

Um, what?

She wants the RCMP to disarm when they are dealing with this blockade in a remote part of B.C. This after we learn the RCMP discovered bags full of gasoline-soaked rags and full jerry cans? There’s not a chance any member of the RCMP should go up there unarmed. 

Keean Bexte of the Rebel Media went up there this week and he reported on sabotaged trees called “widow makers” and tires filled with gas and other inflammables. And yet Govender thinks the RCMP should disarm to deal with these domestic terrorists.  Nonsense.

We also learned from Bexte that so-called Indian band staging the blockade isn’t, but a collection of hereditary chiefs who have broken with the elected Chief and Council and formed this non-profit group. They are being funded by the likes of the Tides Foundation and the Pembina Institute.  

This is yet another example of foreign-funded enviro loons trying to impose their will on Canadians and using bought and paid for First Nations for their nefarious purpose. 

What Govender conveniently ignores is how many First Nations groups support the energy projects to provide employment to their members and cash benefits to the bands. 

Govender has spent her career with a variety of left wing organizations including the Pivot Legal Society, the notorious cop hating, obstructive collection of fools that operate in the Downtown Eastside of Vancouver.

Speaking of Tides, yesterday the Prime Minister’s office announced the appointment of Sarah Goodman as Senior Climate Policy Director. Rather promoted to I should say. She has been working advising the Liberals for the past couple of years. 

The trouble is she is the former Vice President of the Tides Foundation, one of the organizations funding the scam that is the Wet’suwet’en blockade. 

So, a climate activist is now ensconced firmly within the government. Any pretence by the Prime Minister that he wants to work with Alberta has just gone up in smoke. And Tides Foundation fingerprints are on all of this. 

Make no mistake about it, the Tides Foundation is the enemy of the oil and gas sector and as such, the people of Canada. 

With the western separation movement gaining steam, this would seem to be an incredibly foolish move by the Prime Minister. He ignores the west at Canada’s peril. 

FUREY: The world is changing. Is Canada prepared?

We’re seeing countries like Russia and China become more brazen and head in different directions, away from Canada.

The world is changing and foreign affairs is becoming more important than ever. Canada can’t just sit idly by and depend on the United Nations for answers.

True North’s Anthony Furey says this is a discussion that we need to have.

Fan of True North? Help us keep the lights on by making a tax-deductible donation: http://www.tnc.news/donate/

One in five children in Canada are still living in poverty

According to a recent report called “Child and Family Poverty 30 Years Later” one in five children in Canada are currently living in poverty. 

The report, which was published by Campaign 2000 found that more than 1.35 million kids are subjected to poverty nation-wide. 

“The most recent data demonstrates that the rate of child and family poverty continues to be unacceptably high, with 1,356,980 children living in families with after-tax income below the Census Family Low Income Measure, After Tax,” writes the report. 

Among those are 18.6% of children under 18 and 19.6% of preschoolers under the age of 6 years old. 

Poverty rates are the highest among Indigenous and First Nations children, with a shocking 53% of First Nations kids living in poverty on reserves, while another 41% are in poverty off the reserves. 

Nunavut had the highest percentage of child poverty with a rate of 31.2%, followed by the province of Manitoba with 27.9%.

The territory of Yukon had the lowest rate at 11.9% and among the provinces, Quebec reported the low rate of 15.2%. 

Over the last 30 years the poverty rate has overall decreased from 22% to the current rate of 18.6%.

According to recent polls, Canadian families have struggled to stay on top of growing debt and cost of living. In 2019, an Ipsos survey reported that 48% of Canadians are $200 or less away from bankruptcy each month. 


The Trudeau government is expected to release its budget in the upcoming months. A 2019 Fraser Institute report found that the federal government has pushed federal spending to the highest level in Canadian history while running a deficit of $26.6 billion last year.

Poilievre says a Conservative government should not introduce or adopt bills on abortion

Potential Conservative Leadership candidate Pierre Poilievre said in an interview with La Presse that a future Conservative government will not adopt or introduce a bill on abortion if he becomes Prime Minister. He will also prohibit Conservative MPs from introducing private members’ bills on abortion. 

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has a similar policy regarding abortion and has stated that people with pro-life beliefs are not welcome in the Liberal Party. 

In the past, Conservative leaders and leadership candidates have allowed MPs to speak freely on the issue. Even Michael Chong who is considered left-leaning compared to other conservatives vowed to give MPs the right to speak and vote freely on matters of conscience during the 2017 Conservative Leadership Race. 

In the last federal election, Conservative leader Andrew Scheer was constantly questioned on whether he would allow MPs to introduce legislation on abortion or other moral issues. 

“I believe 100% that Members of Parliament have the right to bring forward and debate any legislation of importance to them…Moreover, I have committed that all votes on matters of conscience be free votes,” said Scheer in the past. 

During the interview, Poilievre also announced his support for gay marriage saying that the institution of marriage “must be open” for all.

“I support gay marriages. Period. I voted against 15 years ago. But I learned a lot, like millions and millions of people across Canada and around the world. I find that the gay marriage is a success. The institution of marriage must be open to all citizens, regardless of their sexual orientation,” said Poilievre in French. 

Poilievre is currently considering a bid for the Conservative leadership and has stated that his final decision on whether he will run is “imminent.” 

“Yes, my decision is fairly imminent. We have to wait a little longer,” said Poilievre.

Canada currently has no abortion laws or limits on what term a baby can be aborted. 

Several other prominent Conservatives have already announced their intention to run for Conservative leader including Conservative MP Erin O’Toole and Peter MacKay. 


True North is keeping track of all of the official and unofficial CPC leadership candidates here.

FUREY: Is it time for an outsider to enter the CPC Leadership Race?

The rules for the Conservative Party Leadership are out and it looks like the Party is discouraging outsiders from entering the race.

Is it the right move to discourage individuals outside of the conservative network from entering the race?

True North’s Anthony Furey asks, is it time for an outsider to become the Conservative leader?

Support independent media in Canada by making a tax-deductible donation to True North: http://www.tnc.news/donate/

16,503 people crossed illegally into Canada in 2019: RCMP

According to the RCMP, 16,503 people crossed the border into Canada illegally in 2019. 

In January 2017, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau tweeted an open invitation to the world’s migrants to come to Canada, at the same time the Trump travel ban was enacted in the U.S.

Since then, over 50,000 illegal border crossers have flooded into Canada through the U.S. border. 

In 2018, Canada saw 20,603 people enter the country illegally and claim asylum according to statistics by the Immigration and Refugee Board (IRB). 

IRB officials have recently stated that the board can’t eliminate the ballooning backlog and would require another $400 million from the federal government to clear the claims currently being processed. 

The backlog is expected to grow to 100,000 by 2021 and claims could take five years to be heard while the claimant remains in Canada. 

In a 2019 report, the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that the costs associated with the illegal border crisis would exceed $1.1 billion that year alone.

Recent reports show that a Liberal policy intended on curbing the flow of illegal crossings failed to impact the number of asylum claims made in the country. 

The policy, which prohibited anybody from applying for asylum if they had already done so in another country, only led to the rejection of 400 applications.

Research conducted by the Department of Immigration found that new immigrants were dissatisfied and concerned with the ongoing border situation.

Newcomers to Canada reported in focus groups that the number of illegal border crossers was “disproportionately higher than Canada’s population can absorb.”

Canadian immigrants also expressed concerns about the “loophole” in the Safe Third Country Agreement which allows migrants to claim asylum at unofficial border crossings.

Related stories